Who Should Play Elena Gilbert? Posted on October 11, 2016October 11, 2016 by Popplz With rumors flying around about how Kristen Stewart could take Nina Dobrev’s place as Elena Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries, we decided to ask our readers what they think! Which lady would you like to see play Elena Gilbert? Who Should Play Elena Gilbert? Kristen Stewart Nina Dobrev Share List Related posts Will Emma Watson Make a Good Belle? Should Johnny Depp be in Fantastic Beasts? Who Looked Better on Elle’s Red Carpet?