Who Should Play Elena Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries? Posted on October 26, 2016November 2, 2016 by Popplz With rumors of Kristen Stewart taking Nina Dobrev’s spot in The Vampire Diaries, we want to pose this question to the loyal Popplz readers. Which one of them do you think would be better suited for the role? Who Should Play Elena Gilbert? Kristen Stewart Nina Dobrev Share List Related posts Who is Better for Ian Somerhalder? Who Looked Better on Elle’s Red Carpet? Will Emma Watson Make a Good Belle?